Score: 9

"Fantastic"

submission: Winter Attack (part 1)

date: April 14, 2007

Flawless animation, I've never seen amateur (thats spelt wrong sorry XD) claymation done so smoothly.

It was a cute little short and I'm excited for the next one. =]

Score: 10

"asdlk;jf;alskjdf;j EWWWWW"

submission: Men From Up The Stairs

date: April 11, 2007

Oh dear god, i had no idea what the hell this was about until I read the reviews.

and hear I thought it was just a simple flash with no real meaning.

KLSDJF:LKSJDF:LKJSDF eeeew, lmao, how gross.
Mr Firth you are a very creative man.

Score: 7

"Not sure"

submission: Good Luck Walking

date: April 9, 2007

I really didn't like that we couldn't see the characters at all times, depending on the backround, if you had added some grays it might have helped, but still kept the same feel of the short.

It was interesting, but I would have liked something longer. =]

Score: 6

"Oh dear you poor thing"

submission: Porst

date: April 9, 2007

I often watch things and get inspired and somehow create something similar, so I'm worry you were given so much heap for copying David Firth.

Although this does seem to be an exact copy of "Scribbler"... with his fan base, I'm assuming that was not your intention.

I love dark things. This was too bright, coloring scheme didn't pull me in. But I did like the music and the scene with him in a cage.

I hope to watch your other works and see more originality, as your style is intriguing.

Score: 10

"Sweet Jebus"

submission: Salad Fingers Episode 7

date: February 1, 2006

When I read a past review, before seeing it, I was worried there was going to be something ultra gorey but there wasn't.

Very odd... like the rest. I'd have to say this one isn't your best, but they are still quite good.

PLEASE update with more cartoons, not just scarey ones or just continueing your serieses.

Score: 10

"Completely Amazing"

submission: littleFoot

date: December 2, 2005

I've never seen anything this good, you MUST continue soon.

Now I see why you're #1!!

Score: 10

"Wonderfully enjoyable"

submission: -Let it B-

date: December 1, 2005

Anything with the Beatles and animation like that gets a ten.

Score: 10

"I've watched every Foamy..."

submission: Unmentionable Auction

date: November 29, 2005

....and they are all brilliant. There's one every two weeks? SCORE!

Score: 10

"HILARIOUS"

submission: Charlie the Unicorn

date: November 29, 2005

Omg that was great. I totally thought you were taking it somewhere else but that was just genius!

Score: 7

"Nicely drawn Foamy..."

submission: Foamy's Death Sentance

date: November 29, 2005

Understandable if you don't like Foamy (I myself am a fan, but hey, not everyone loves everything, ya know?). It was pretty funny, but I think you should have added more to it, ya know? Hopefully the next one isn't as boring, sorry to say.

This is like Salad Fingers Hunter. They would be better if they were longer. But both of you are doing more, so its all good.

Later.